FCA Record Keeping for Mortgage Brokers: What to Keep

FCA Record Keeping for Mortgage Brokers: What to Keep

UK mortgage brokers must keep orderly records of their business and internal organisation, including every service provided and every transaction, so the FCA can monitor compliance. Retention periods then depend on the record type: the MCOB schedule sets periods from one year to the life of a contract, and none of them is a blanket seven years. This guide sets out what to keep, for how long, in what form, and how to make document checks leave a usable trail.

TL;DR

  • Brokers must keep orderly records of their business and internal organisation, covering services, transactions, advice and correspondence with customers and third parties.
  • MCOB Schedule 1 sets record-specific periods: one year, three years, five years and the term of the contract, depending on the record. There is no single seven-year rule.
  • Records can be held in any form, but they must be readily accessible, meaning available for inspection within two business days, and protected against alteration or loss.
  • Document checks (bank statements, payslips, ID) are part of the file. The trail showing what was received, when, and what was checked is as important as the documents.

Table of Contents

What the FCA expects from a broker's records

The starting point is a general duty. A firm must keep orderly records of its business and internal organisation, including all services and transactions it undertakes. The purpose is practical: the FCA must be able to monitor whether the firm is meeting its obligations to clients (FCA Handbook).

The same guidance sets the working principle for retention. Records should be kept for as long as they are relevant to the purpose for which they were made. The specific periods in the Handbook are minimums that apply to defined record types. Beyond them, the principle is a judgement the firm must be able to justify.

Two features matter for a brokerage in practice:

  • The duty is about being orderly, not just about keeping. A folder of unlabelled PDFs does not meet it. Someone other than the adviser who built the file should be able to follow what happened.
  • Systems and controls are expected. Firms should have appropriate systems and controls covering the adequacy, access and security of records. A policy that exists only on paper does not cover this.

Which records a mortgage broker must keep

As a minimum, firms should retain records of advice given and of correspondence with customers and third parties. Electronic communications are included. That covers emails, text messages and other electronic messages between the firm, or anyone acting for it, and a customer.

In a typical regulated mortgage case, the file therefore needs to hold:

  1. Customer information gathered for the advice, including the fact-find and the explanations behind the recommendation.
  2. The suitability record, showing why the product recommended fitted the customer's needs and circumstances.
  3. Correspondence: emails, messages and notes of calls with the client, the lender, solicitors and any other third party.
  4. Offer documents issued to the customer.
  5. Supporting evidence the broker collected or reviewed: identity documents, proof of address, payslips, bank statements, tax records and evidence of commitments.
  6. Internal records of how the file was handled: who reviewed what, which queries were raised, and how they were resolved.

Items 1 to 4 map directly onto rules. Items 5 and 6 are where firms most often have gaps, and where a complaint or file review is usually decided. If a customer later disputes the advice, the evidence behind the recommendation matters as much as the recommendation.

How long to keep each type of record

MCOB Schedule 1 lists record-specific retention periods. The ones most relevant to a mortgage brokerage are below. Always check the schedule itself for the full list and the exact trigger for each record.

Record typeMinimum periodTrigger
Offer documentsOne yearVaries by record; see the schedule
Suitability and advice records for a regulated mortgage contractThree yearsThe date the advice was given
Certain sale and rent back recordsFive years or longerVaries by record; see the schedule
Some records tied to a contractThe term of the contractPer the schedule

The figures come from MCOB Schedule 1. The suitability record is the one most brokers focus on: records covering customer information and the explanation for the advice must be retained for three years from the date the advice was given.

Is there a seven-year rule?

No single FCA rule requires a broker to keep all business records for seven years. The periods vary by record type, as the table shows. Seven years is a common figure in firms' own policies, often because it lines up with limitation periods for legal claims or with other legislation. That is a reasonable choice, but it is a firm's policy decision rather than an FCA requirement. Say so in your retention policy, so the reasoning is on record.

Is there a seven-year rule?

Why many firms keep records longer

The Handbook sets minimums. Firms may choose to retain records for longer to manage the risk of customer complaints or legal action. The FCA's approach recognises that a record can stay useful beyond the mandatory minimum, and leaves the firm to use professional judgement based on the legal and complaint-handling landscape.

A workable approach:

  1. Set a minimum period for each record type, taken from the schedule.
  2. Decide a longer period where you can explain why, for example for files where advice was complex.
  3. Write the reasoning into the retention policy.
  4. Apply the policy consistently, including deletion once the period ends.

That last step is easy to forget. Personal data should not be held indefinitely without reason, so a retention schedule needs a deletion routine as well as a keeping routine. Our guide to data retention for mortgage brokers covers how the two obligations fit together.

How records must be stored and retrieved

The FCA does not prescribe a format. Firms may store records in any form they choose, provided they are readily accessible. Accessible here means available for inspection within two business days. Electronic records must be protected against unauthorised alteration or accidental loss.

In plain terms, three tests apply to your storage setup.

1. Can you produce a file within two business days?

This is a test of organisation more than technology. If documents sit across email inboxes, adviser desktops and a shared drive with inconsistent naming, producing a complete file for one client can take days. A single record per case, with consistent labelling, makes this test easy.

2. Does the stored record match the original?

For electronic records, firms should take reasonable steps to ensure the record accurately reflects the original information and has not been altered, whether deliberately or by accident. This is where version control matters. If a client uploads a corrected payslip, the earlier version should not vanish or be overwritten silently. See our note on document version control for UK mortgage brokers for how to handle replacements.

3. Is the record protected against loss?

Backups are part of the answer, and so is knowing how long they are kept. Backup retention affects how far back you can restore a file if something is deleted or corrupted, so it is worth reading about how long backups last and aligning that period with your own retention schedule. A backup cycle shorter than your retention period leaves a gap.

Records of document checks: the part that is easy to miss

Regulators and lenders do not only ask what documents are on file. They ask what the firm did with them. A strong file shows:

  • what was requested, from whom, and when;
  • what was received and when;
  • who reviewed each document and what they found;
  • which discrepancies were raised and how they were resolved;
  • which version was finally submitted to the lender.

This is an audit trail. It protects the broker when a lender queries a case months later, and it supports the "orderly records" duty by showing how the file was built, not only its end state.

Several checks produce evidence that needs recording:

Changes to a file are part of the same record. A change management log shows who altered what and when, which answers the "unauthorised or accidental alteration" concern directly.

A practical record-keeping routine for a small brokerage

Small firms do not need heavy process, but they do need a consistent one. This routine fits most brokerages.

  1. Open one file per case at the start. Everything related to the client goes in it: fact-find, documents, messages and notes.
  2. Name documents consistently. Applicant, document type and date make files searchable and quick to produce.
  3. Log requests and receipts. Record what was asked for and what arrived. Chasing by email without a log leaves no trail.
  4. Record the review. Note who checked each document and the outcome, including any discrepancy found.
  5. Keep superseded versions. Replace nothing silently. Mark older versions as superseded.
  6. Capture communications. Emails and messages with the client and third parties belong on the file, not only in personal inboxes.
  7. Store the suitability record with the case. It carries the three-year minimum from the date of advice.
  8. Apply the retention schedule. Diarise review dates, delete when the period ends, and log the deletion.
  9. Test retrieval. Once a quarter, pick a closed case and produce its full file. If it takes more than a few minutes, the structure needs work.

Where manual processes fail

Manual document handling creates predictable record-keeping problems:

  • Documents arrive by email, WhatsApp and post, and only some reach the file.
  • Different advisers name and store files differently.
  • Reviews are done but not recorded, so the work cannot be evidenced.
  • Discrepancies, such as a wage deposit that does not match a payslip, are spotted late or not logged.
  • Replacement documents overwrite originals.

None of these is a failure of intent. They arise because the process depends on individual habits. Moving collection and review into a single system with a built-in log removes most of them. For a view on which tasks suit automation, see mortgage broker automation: what to automate and what to keep.

Our perspective

Most record-keeping problems we see in brokerages start at collection, not at storage. A file is only as orderly as the way documents entered it. If clients send documents by several routes and advisers review them informally, the record has gaps before anyone thinks about retention periods.

We built Casefile around that point. It collects client documents through a branded portal, builds the document list from the client's payment types, and cross-checks bank statements, payslips and tax forms so that issues such as undeclared commitments or mismatched wage deposits surface before a lender sees the case. Each step leaves an audit trail, so the file shows what was requested, received and checked.

Data residency is part of the same discipline. Casefile keeps data in the UK, with no manual or offshore handling, which keeps the record-keeping position simple to explain. For smaller brokerages, the benefit is practical: fewer manual checks, clearer client communication, and files that are ready to produce when asked.

Darren

Build the audit trail into document collection

Casefile automates document collection and review for UK mortgage brokers. Documents arrive through a portal carrying your brokerage's branding, the checklist adapts to each applicant, and discrepancies are flagged before submission. The result is a file with a clear record of every request, upload and check. You can see more at Casefile, or read how Casefile handles your documents.

Gocasefile

Pricing is arranged with the Casefile team after onboarding and set-up, so contact them through the site for current terms.

FAQ

How long must a mortgage broker keep client records under FCA rules?

It depends on the record. MCOB Schedule 1 sets periods including one year for offer documents, three years for suitability and advice records, and five years or longer for certain sale and rent back records. Suitability records run from the date the advice was given. Check the schedule for the exact trigger for each record type.

Do I have to keep all business records for seven years?

Not under the FCA rules. Retention periods are record-specific. Many firms choose a longer, uniform period for simplicity or to cover legal claims, which is permitted because the Handbook sets minimums. If you adopt seven years, record it as your firm's policy and the reason for it.

Can I keep records electronically?

Yes. Firms may store records in any form, provided they are readily accessible within two business days and protected against unauthorised alteration or accidental loss. Reasonable steps must be taken to ensure the stored version accurately reflects the original.

Do emails and text messages count as records?

Yes. The guidance includes emails, text messages and other electronic communications between the firm, or someone acting for it, and a customer. These should be retained for as long as they remain relevant to the purpose for which they were made.

Sources

This article was generated with AI, and whilst it is our expectation that the article is accurate, it should not be taken as advice.