Bonus Income Verification: 5 Checks for UK Mortgage Brokers

Bonus Income Verification: 5 Checks for UK Mortgage Brokers

Bonus income verification means proving that a client's bonus, overtime or commission is real, regular and large enough for a lender to use in affordability. In practice, a broker matches payslips, a P60 or HMRC Annual Tax Summary and bank statements against each other, then checks the result against the individual lender's rules. This guide sets out what lenders accept, how they weight variable pay, and five checks that catch problems before a case reaches underwriting.

TL;DR

  • Lenders treat bonus, overtime and commission (often shortened to BOC) as variable income. It must usually be regular, evidenced on payslips and, for larger amounts, backed by a P60.
  • Weighting differs by lender: some use 100% of a lowest or averaged figure, others use 60% or 70%. Check the lender's criteria before you choose it.
  • Payslips, P60 and bank statements must tell the same story. A mismatch in any one of them is the usual cause of a query.
  • Collect the right documents for each client's pay frequency at the start, not after the first underwriter request.

Table of Contents

What counts as bonus and overtime income

Lenders do not treat all extra pay alike. The questions they ask are how often it is paid, whether it is guaranteed, and whether the pattern is stable.

Santander's evidence guide says bonus, commission or overtime used as primary income at 100% must be regular and consistent, not a short-term trend. Where the amounts are regular but vary, Santander uses an average of the last 3 months' payslips multiplied by 12, and treats it as secondary income at 70%.

The broker's first job is therefore classification. For each client, record:

  1. The type: bonus, overtime, commission, shift allowance or additional duty hours.
  2. The frequency: weekly, fortnightly, monthly, quarterly, half-yearly or annual.
  3. Whether it is guaranteed in the contract or discretionary.
  4. How long the client has received it, and whether the employer has changed.

This classification decides which documents you request and which lenders are realistic.

Documents that verify variable income

The core set is the same across most lenders: payslips, a P60 or HMRC Annual Tax Summary, and bank statements. The number of each depends on how often the extra pay arrives.

Barclays' packaging checklist states that for monthly or weekly bonus, overtime or commission, the broker provides 3 months' payslips, the latest P60 or Annual Tax Summary, and 3 full months of consecutive bank statements. For quarterly or annual bonus, it asks for the payslips where the bonus was received, two years of P60s, Annual Tax Summaries or payslips showing receipt, and the same 3 months of statements. That checklist is dated September 2018, so confirm the current version on the lender's site.

Evidence by pay frequency

The table shows a sample of published requirements. Lenders revise these, so treat it as a guide to the pattern and confirm the detail before submission.

LenderFrequencyEvidence required
SantanderAnnual bonus or commissionLatest payslip showing the payment, plus the previous payslip or P60 evidencing the prior tax year's payment (source)
TSBMonthly bonusLatest 3 payslips; 6 if paid weekly or fortnightly (source)
TSBAnnual bonusLatest payslip showing it, within the last 12 months, or an employer's reference (source)
Virgin MoneyCommission or overtimeLatest 2 payslips if monthly or 4-weekly, 4 if fortnightly, 8 if weekly (source)
BarclaysQuarterly, half-yearly, annual bonus8, 4 and 2 payslips respectively evidencing the payment (source)

Two details cause avoidable delays. HSBC states that the latest month's payslip must be dated within the last 35 days for employed residential customers. Santander does not accept an employer's handwritten or amended income reference as proof of income. A client who sends an old payslip or a hand-edited letter creates a request you could have prevented.

When the P60 is missing

Clients lose P60s often. Virgin Money's sales aid lists the alternatives it accepts: the last payslip of the previous tax year, a duplicate P60 from the employer, a P45 from a previous employer, a letter from HMRC, or an employer's statement of earnings on letterhead. Ask for the substitute at the outset when the client says the P60 cannot be found.

How lenders weight bonus and overtime

Same client, same payslips, different usable income. That is the practical reason to understand weighting before you pick a lender.

Some detail is easy to miss. Nationwide requires an annual bonus to be on both payslips supplied, and a half-yearly bonus on at least 2 of 4 proofs including the latest, according to its employment income criteria. Barclays requires the gross, pre-tax figure for an annual bonus, paid by the current employer within the last 12 months, and does not require 2 years with that employer.

Because variable income is often scaled down, it also changes the picture lenders see for existing debts. Broker-side context on how debt-to-income ratios are calculated and judged helps explain why a reduced income figure can alter lender fit for applicants with variable pay.

How lenders weight bonus and overtime

5 checks to cross-verify bonus and overtime figures

Evidence only helps when the documents agree. Run these five checks on every case that includes variable pay.

1. Confirm the pay pattern on the payslips

Identify whether the bonus or overtime appears on the required number of payslips. Barclays asks the broker to check whether overtime or commission shows on at least one of the most recent 3 months' payslips before averaging. Note any month with a nil entry, because Nationwide includes £0 months in its average.

2. Average the payslips and annualise

Take the monthly variable amounts from the last 3 payslips, average them and multiply by 12. Compare that against the lender's method, whether that is the lowest month (Santander's primary income approach) or the average.

3. Reconcile against the P60

Barclays' method for monthly overtime or commission is a useful model. Deduct salary, allowances and any bonus paid less often than monthly from the P60 total, divide the remainder by 12, and then take the lower of the 3-month average and the P60 monthly average. If the P60 figure is far below the payslip run rate, the variable pay may be recent, which affects both lender choice and the income you can use.

4. Match the deposits on bank statements

The net pay on each payslip should appear as a deposit on the statements, on the right date, from the right employer. Variable pay that never reaches the account, or arrives in a different amount, needs an explanation before submission. Bank statements also reveal commitments the client left off the fact find. Our guide to income verification in the UK covers the field-by-field comparison in more depth.

5. Check the documents themselves

Look at dates, employer name, tax code, year-to-date figures and formatting consistency. Payslips that are out of date or edited are a common source of rejection, and our mortgage fraud red flags checklist lists the patterns to watch for.

What to do when the figures do not match

Mismatches are normal. Salary rises, job changes and one-off bonuses all distort a P60 relative to current payslips. The question is whether you can explain the gap with evidence.

Paradigm's guidance on acceptable income types states that if a P60 cannot be provided, or its figure does not correlate with the payslips because of a salary increase, change of job or one-off bonus payment, 6 months' payslips are required. It is a good example of a lender asking for a longer run of evidence to settle a discrepancy.

A practical order of response:

  1. Identify which document is the outlier and why: a pay rise, a new employer, a one-off bonus.
  2. Ask the client for the document that explains it: a longer run of payslips, a P45, an employer letter on letterhead.
  3. Rework the income on the lower, supportable figure if the explanation is incomplete.
  4. Add a short case note to the submission that explains the gap, so the underwriter does not have to ask.
  5. Re-check lender fit if the supportable figure is now smaller than the one you planned on.

Preparing the client file

Most delay comes from chasing. NatWest notes that for new business, brokers have 14 calendar days to upload the full requested packaging, with the day of submission counted as day 1. It also says free scanning apps help split a combined file of payslips and statements into separate documents and improve quality. A clear document list at the start saves most of that time.

Preparing the client file

Build the list around the client's pay type, not a generic template. A client paid weekly with overtime needs more payslips than a salaried client with an annual bonus, and a client with sideline self-employment alongside a job needs tax documents as well. For those clients, a sole trader tax and CIS checklist shows what tidy records look like, and our guide to tax return verification covers the broker-side checks. Our mortgage onboarding workflow sets out the stages from first contact to submission.

Perspective: why variable income should be checked before submission

Variable income is where document checks stop being a tick-box exercise. A payslip can be genuine and still fail to support the income on the application, because the pattern, the P60 and the bank deposits do not line up.

We built Casefile around that problem. The document list builds itself from the client's payment type, so a client paid weekly with overtime is asked for different evidence than a salaried client. The platform cross-checks payslips, bank statements and tax documents, matches wage deposits and highlights discrepancies, including undeclared commitments, before the case reaches the lender.

For smaller brokerages this matters most. Manual comparison of three documents per income stream takes time that advisers do not have, and every lender query adds days. Our aim is that the broker sees the issue first, resolves it with the client, and submits a file that holds together. Data stays within the UK, there is a clear audit trail, and the client-facing experience carries the brokerage's own branding.

Darren

Automating the cross-check with Casefile

Casefile is a cloud-based platform for UK mortgage brokers that collects client documents, cross-checks payslips, bank statements, tax forms, ID and utility bills, and flags discrepancies, tampering and undeclared commitments before submission. It manages the approval queue, supports multiple applicant types and keeps data in the UK. See how it works on the Casefile site, or read how Casefile handles your documents.

Gocasefile

For wider context on what to automate and what to keep with the adviser, see our guide to mortgage broker automation.

FAQ

Do lenders use 100% of a client's bonus income?

Not always. Santander uses regular and consistent variable pay at 100% as primary income, while Virgin Money uses 60% for most bonus, overtime and commission. TSB accepts bonus at 100% but uses 60%. Check the specific lender's criteria before recommending it.

How many payslips are needed to evidence overtime?

It depends on the lender and pay frequency. TSB asks for the latest 3 payslips if paid monthly and 6 if paid weekly or fortnightly. Virgin Money asks for 2 monthly, 4 fortnightly or 8 weekly payslips. Always use the current packaging page of the lender you have chosen.

Is a P60 always required for bonus income?

No, but it is often needed. Barclays requires a P60 where more than 50% of the 3-month average BOC income is used, and two years where more than 100% is used. If the P60 is lost, lenders such as Virgin Money accept alternatives like a duplicate from the employer or a letter from HMRC.

Can a new bonus be used if the client changed jobs?

Sometimes. Barclays states the customer does not need 2 years with the same employer for an annual bonus, but the latest bonus must have been paid by the current employer within the last 12 months. Other lenders differ, so confirm the rule before submission.

Sources

This article was generated with AI, and whilst it is our expectation that the article is accurate, it should not be taken as advice.